HVAC, explained
Radiant barriers in an attic: placement and dust
A radiant barrier needs an air space next to its reflective side to be effective (Virginia Tech Extension). FSEC advises against placing radiant barrier material directly on top of attic insulation (FSEC). In time, the dust will negate the radiant barrier effect (FSEC).
The sections below set out what the Florida Solar Energy Center (FSEC), Virginia Tech Cooperative Extension, ENERGY STAR and Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) say about radiant barriers in attics. FSEC describes radiant barriers as a mature energy-saving technology first evaluated in the late 1950s (FSEC). FSEC's study authors recommend that radiant barriers be considered for homes with shingle roofs (FSEC). In the U.S., heating and cooling account for the largest annual uses of electricity in the residential sector (EIA).
What a radiant barrier needs to work
A radiant heat barrier must have an air space next to a reflective side to be effective (Virginia Tech Extension). It cannot be sandwiched between two materials, because the air space is critical to its performance (Virginia Tech Extension). A radiant barrier still needs insulation, due to the way heat is transferred (Virginia Tech Extension).
There is no current method for assigning an R-value to radiant barriers (Virginia Tech Extension).
Which way the foil faces
In attics, single-sided radiant barrier material should be installed with the foil side facing down (FSEC). A barrier attached to the underside of the roof deck faces its foil toward the attic air space (Virginia Tech Extension).
FSEC says dust can degrade radiant barrier performance, so roof-mounted application is preferred over horizontal application (FSEC).
Why it should not sit on top of insulation
FSEC advises against placing radiant barrier material directly on top of attic insulation (FSEC). When a barrier sits over the insulation, dust builds up on the foil side that faces the roof (FSEC). In time, the dust will negate the radiant barrier effect (FSEC).
Virginia Tech Extension says barriers should be installed to prevent dust build-up, as dust and dirt will decrease their effectiveness (Virginia Tech Extension).
Installation cautions
FSEC advises taking care to avoid compressing existing attic insulation during installation (FSEC). FSEC says proper installation probably offers the greatest potential for performance gains (FSEC). ENERGY STAR says never to lay insulation over recessed light fixtures or soffit vents (ENERGY STAR).
ENERGY STAR calls blocking airflow at the eaves the most common insulation mistake homeowners make (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says never to cover attic soffit vents with insulation (ENERGY STAR).
Ventilation and attic airflow
FSEC says ventilation from soffit to peak improves radiant barrier system performance (FSEC). FSEC says effective attic ventilation can significantly improve radiant barrier performance (FSEC).
ENERGY STAR says an unfinished attic should not be cooled by the air conditioner (ENERGY STAR).
What the lab, model and Florida roof tests found
An ORNL lab test found that radiant barriers and low-emittance coatings can significantly reduce conditioning loads from heat flow through attic floors. The test used a large-scale climate simulator (ORNL).
An FSEC attic model study found that the relative degree of stratification is greater when radiant barriers are in place (FSEC).
In a Fort Myers roofing study, the attic temperature during the peak summer hour was 40 degrees Fahrenheit above ambient air in the control home (FSEC). The control home had no radiant barrier, so the figure does not measure a barrier's effect (FSEC).
In the same study, a sealed attic with R-19 deck insulation gave modest cooling savings but no real peak reduction (FSEC). That comparison was with a control house, not with a radiant barrier (FSEC).
Attic work safety and when to hire help
During hot weather, ENERGY STAR advises starting attic work early, because attics heat up as the day goes on (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says a homeowner should consult or hire a professional to correct attic conditions before proceeding, if the homeowner finds them (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says loose-fill insulation may call for a professional, because the application requires a blowing machine (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says a contractor can be considered to complete an attic insulation project (ENERGY STAR).
Blume Mechanical Service repairs, installs and maintains HVAC and refrigeration equipment.
Frequently asked
Can a radiant barrier go directly on top of attic insulation?
FSEC says placing the material directly on top of insulation is not recommended (FSEC). When a barrier sits over the insulation, dust builds up on the foil side that faces the roof (FSEC).
Which way should the foil face?
In attics, single-sided radiant barrier material should be installed with the foil side facing down (FSEC). A barrier attached to the underside of the roof deck faces its foil toward the attic air space (Virginia Tech Extension).
Does a radiant barrier replace attic insulation?
Virginia Tech Extension says a radiant barrier still needs insulation, due to the way heat is transferred (Virginia Tech Extension). There is no current method for assigning an R-value to radiant barriers (Virginia Tech Extension).
Does ventilation affect a radiant barrier?
FSEC says ventilation from soffit to peak improves radiant barrier system performance (FSEC). FSEC says effective attic ventilation can significantly improve radiant barrier performance (FSEC).
Should I hire a contractor for the work?
ENERGY STAR says a contractor can be considered to complete an attic insulation project (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says to consult or hire a professional to correct attic conditions before proceeding, if the homeowner finds them (ENERGY STAR).
Does dust matter over time?
In time, the dust will negate the radiant barrier effect (FSEC). Virginia Tech Extension says dust and dirt will decrease their effectiveness (Virginia Tech Extension).
Related
- Refrigerant types explained: R-22, R-410A, R-32, R-454B
- When air conditioning became common in U.S. homes
- Attic insulation R-value: how to check your attic
Blume Mechanical Service repairs, installs and maintains HVAC and refrigeration equipment, is licensed under CAC-1822618, and serves Pinellas, Hillsborough and Pasco counties. Call 727-330-9131 for HVAC questions.
Sources: Florida Solar Energy Center (University of Central Florida) — Radiant Barriers: A Question and Answer Primer (FSEC-EN-15) (https://www.fsec.ucf.edu/en/publications/html/FSEC-EN-15/) · Florida Solar Energy Center (University of Central Florida) — Radiant Barrier (https://energyresearch.ucf.edu/research/buildings-research/roof-assembly/radiant-barrier/) · Florida Solar Energy Center (University of Central Florida) — FPC Residential Monitoring Project: New Technology Development - Radiant Barrier Pilot Project (https://fsec.ucf.edu/en/publications/html/FSEC-CR-1231-01/) · Florida Solar Energy Center (University of Central Florida) — A Stratified Air Model for Simulation of Attic Thermal Performance (https://fsec.ucf.edu/en/publications/html/FSEC-PF-226-91/) · Florida Solar Energy Center (University of Central Florida) — Comparative Evaluation of the Impact of Roofing Systems (https://fsec.ucf.edu/en/publications/html/FSEC-CR-1220-00/) · Virginia Tech Cooperative Extension — ENERGY SERIES: What about Radiant Barriers? (https://pubs.ext.vt.edu/2908/2908-9021/2908-9021.html) · U.S. EPA ENERGY STAR — About Attic Ventilation (https://www.energystar.gov/saveathome/seal_insulate/do-it-yourself-guide/about-attic-ventilation) · U.S. EPA ENERGY STAR — Attic Insulation Project (https://www.energystar.gov/saveathome/seal_insulate/attic-insulation-project) · Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) — Thermal performance evaluation of attic radiant barrier systems using the large scale climate simulator (LSCS) (https://www.ornl.gov/publication/thermal-performance-evaluation-attic-radiant-barrier-systems-using-large-scale-climate) · U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) — Use of electricity (https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/use-of-electricity.php)