HVAC, explained
Rooftop unit replacement efficiency: what to check
Rooftop units over 15 years old can waste substantial energy and money while providing less-than-quality service (DOE). Federal dates and refrigerant rules apply to some new systems, so check them before you choose a model (DOE, EPA). Ask a licensed contractor to compare the cost of repairs with the cost of a replacement for your unit.
Facility managers may be deciding whether to replace a rooftop unit now or later. DOE says facility managers often wait for rooftop units to die a slow, expensive death or fail completely before replacing them (DOE). The sections below cover unit age, the business case for earlier replacement, federal compliance dates, refrigerant rules and ENERGY STAR labels.
Rooftop unit age and energy waste
Rooftop units over 15 years old can waste substantial energy and money while providing less-than-quality service (DOE). That statement is about age, so pair it with the unit's condition and repair history. Ask a licensed contractor to compare the cost of further repairs with the cost of a replacement.
Waiting for a rooftop unit to fail
DOE says facility managers often wait for rooftop units to die a slow, expensive death or fail completely before replacing them (DOE). DOE describes this as common practice, not as a rule that every unit must be replaced early (DOE).
DOE's Advanced RTU Campaign published a business case for a proactive high-efficiency RTU replacement strategy (DOE). Ask a licensed contractor to run that comparison with your unit's repair history.
DOE compliance dates for air-cooled units
DOE says compliance with the standards established in its direct final rule for air-cooled units is required on and after January 1, 2029 (DOE). The rule covers the air-cooled unitary units that DOE's page lists (DOE).
DOE says amended test procedures will be mandatory for testing covered equipment starting May 15, 2025 (DOE). DOE says its certification, compliance and enforcement regulations are in the CFR at 10 CFR Part 429 (DOE). Confirm with the manufacturer which of these dates apply to the model you are considering.
Refrigerant rules for R-410A and new systems
EPA says the import of R-410A residential and light commercial air conditioning products is prohibited starting January 1, 2025 (EPA). EPA says the manufacture of those products is prohibited from the same date (EPA). EPA says components using R-410A cannot be used to install a new R-410A system beginning January 1, 2026 (EPA).
EPA says that after January 1, 2026, a whole new system that is installed must use lower-GWP refrigerant, for the residential and light commercial systems its FAQ covers (EPA). EPA also says the rule prohibits the installation of certain refrigeration, air conditioning and heat pump systems (EPA). EPA is restricting the installation of new field-assembled systems (EPA).
EPA's sector tables are for information only and should not be relied on for compliance (EPA). For a compliance decision, read the regulation text and ask your contractor which rule applies to the model you choose.
What the ENERGY STAR label covers
ENERGY STAR says certified light commercial HVAC equipment is designed to reduce energy waste and save money on utility bills (ENERGY STAR). That statement applies only to certified models, so confirm a model's certification before you rely on it (ENERGY STAR).
ENERGY STAR says its light commercial HVAC specification is currently under revision (ENERGY STAR). Ask the manufacturer which specification version a model is certified against.
ENERGY STAR criteria and sizing
ENERGY STAR tells buyers to look for the ENERGY STAR when choosing light commercial heating and cooling equipment (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says a light commercial HVAC product must meet every listed criterion to earn the label (ENERGY STAR).
For small commercial air-cooled units of 65,000 to under 135,000 Btu/h with electric resistance heat or no heat, ENERGY STAR lists 12.7 EER and 18.0 IEER (ENERGY STAR). Units with other heating types are listed on a separate row (ENERGY STAR).
ENERGY STAR says properly sized equipment dramatically cuts energy costs, increases equipment life and reduces pollution (ENERGY STAR). Ask your contractor how the unit was sized for your building.
Economizers and hot-climate purchasing
DOE's operations and maintenance guidance on economizers focuses specifically on air-side economizers, also known as outside air economizers (DOE). That practice is not a rule that every rooftop unit must have an economizer (DOE).
DOE says air-side economizers are common throughout the United States because of their cost effectiveness (DOE). DOE also says realizing the potential savings requires that economizers are operated correctly and maintained adequately (DOE). Ask your contractor whether the economizer on your unit is operated and maintained as designed.
DOE's federal purchasing guidance says that in hot climates, buyers should consider installing central air conditioners that exceed minimum performance requirements (DOE). That guidance is for federal purchasing and is not a rooftop-unit rule (DOE).
Questions to ask before you request quotes
Collect the unit's age and its repair history before you request quotes, so each contractor works from the same facts. Ask every contractor which federal dates and refrigerant rules apply to the model they propose. Ask whether the proposal includes a sizing calculation for your building.
Frequently asked
What age does DOE flag for rooftop units?
DOE says rooftop units over 15 years old can waste substantial energy and money while providing less-than-quality service (DOE). Ask a licensed contractor to compare repair and replacement costs for your unit.
Should I wait for a rooftop unit to fail?
DOE says facility managers often wait for rooftop units to die a slow, expensive death or fail completely before replacing them (DOE). DOE also says its Advanced RTU Campaign published a business case for proactive high-efficiency replacement (DOE).
When does the DOE compliance date start?
DOE says compliance with the standards in its direct final rule for air-cooled units is required on and after January 1, 2029 (DOE). The rule covers the air-cooled unitary units that DOE's page lists (DOE).
Must a new system use lower-GWP refrigerant?
EPA says that after January 1, 2026, a whole new system that is installed must use lower-GWP refrigerant, for the residential and light commercial systems its FAQ covers (EPA). Ask your contractor which refrigerant the model you choose uses.
What does an ENERGY STAR label say about bills?
ENERGY STAR says certified light commercial HVAC equipment is designed to reduce energy waste and save money on utility bills (ENERGY STAR). That statement applies only to certified models (ENERGY STAR).
Is the ENERGY STAR specification current?
ENERGY STAR says its light commercial HVAC specification is currently under revision (ENERGY STAR). Ask the manufacturer which specification version a model is certified against.
Related
- Commercial refrigeration and food safety temperatures
- Ducts that sweat: moisture and condensation
- AC Repair or Replace: A Framework for Deciding
Need a rooftop unit assessment or replacement quote? Blume Mechanical Service (license CAC-1822618) repairs, installs and maintains HVAC and refrigeration equipment, is brand-agnostic, and serves Pinellas, Hillsborough and Pasco counties. Call 727-330-9131.
Sources: U.S. DOE — What is the #1 Way to Save Money on Your Rooftop Unit? Fix it BEFORE it Breaks (https://www.energy.gov/cmei/buildings/articles/what-1-way-save-money-your-rooftop-unit-fix-it-it-breaks) · U.S. DOE — Air-Cooled Unitary Air Conditioners and Heat Pumps (https://www.energy.gov/cmei/buildings/air-cooled-unitary-air-conditioners-and-heat-pumps) · U.S. EPA — Frequent Questions on the Phasedown of Hydrofluorocarbons (https://www.epa.gov/hfcs/frequent-questions-phasedown-hydrofluorocarbons) · U.S. EPA — Technology Transitions HFC Restrictions by Sector (https://www.epa.gov/hfcs/technology-transitions-hfc-restrictions-sector) · ENERGY STAR — Light Commercial Heating & Cooling (https://www.energystar.gov/products/light_comm_heating_cooling) · ENERGY STAR — ENERGY STAR Light Commercial HVAC Version 4.0 specification (https://www.energystar.gov/products/spec/energy_star_light_commercial_hvac_version_4_0_pd) · U.S. DOE — Equipment Operations and Maintenance Summaries (https://www.energy.gov/cmei/femp/equipment-operations-and-maintenance-summaries) · U.S. DOE — Purchasing Energy-Efficient Light Commercial Heating and Cooling Equipment (https://www.energy.gov/cmei/femp/purchasing-energy-efficient-light-commercial-heating-and-cooling-equipment) · ENERGY STAR — Light Commercial HVAC Key Product Criteria (https://www.energystar.gov/products/light_comm_heating_cooling/light_commercial_hvac_key_product_criteria)