HVAC, explained
What tape to use on air conditioning ducts
Use mastic sealant or metal (foil) tape to seal duct leaks, not ordinary duct tape (ENERGY STAR). Cloth duct tape is the wrong choice, and LBNL found that fabric-backed tapes with rubber adhesives failed more rapidly than other duct sealants (LBNL). In LBNL's own reported test, the early cloth-backed tape samples showed visible failure within about three days, while metal-backed tapes, aerosol sealant and mastic showed no visible or measurable degradation after two weeks (LBNL).
LBNL says duct leakage is a major energy-loss problem in residential buildings (LBNL). LBNL says tapes or mastics put around the joints are typical ways to seal ducts (LBNL). ENERGY STAR says that in forced-air systems, leaks, holes and poorly connected ducts lead to an inefficient system and high utility bills (ENERGY STAR).
Which tape to use on ducts
ENERGY STAR says to start by sealing leaks with mastic sealant or metal (foil) tape, and to never use duct tape, which it says is not long-lasting (ENERGY STAR). DOE says duct joints should be sealed with mastic, approved metal tape or flex duct fasteners (DOE). If a joint must stay accessible for future maintenance, DOE recommends pressure- or heat-sensitive aluminum foil tape (DOE). LBNL says foil tape is often used on rigid duct systems such as duct board (LBNL).
Why cloth duct tape fails
DOE says that duct tape made of plastic or cloth should not be used on ducts, since it dries out, cracks and quickly loses its bond (DOE). LBNL describes duct tape as typically cloth-backed with a rubber-based adhesive (LBNL). In LBNL's 1998 article, the authors said that of all the things they tested, only duct tape failed (LBNL, 1998). The same article says that, as a sealant, duct tape may not last long, while in the short run it is sticky and easy to use (LBNL, 1998).
Where ducts leak
ENERGY STAR says that ducts hidden in walls, ceilings, attics and basements can be tricky to fix (ENERGY STAR). Its flyer says to start by inspecting the ducts you can see, such as those in the basement, attic and garage (ENERGY STAR). The connections at vents and registers, where a duct meets floors, walls or ceilings, are common places to find leaks and disconnected ductwork (ENERGY STAR). The flyer also says pollutants can enter ducts from dusty attics or musty crawlspaces (ENERGY STAR). Among common duct problems, the flyer lists leaks at the furnace and filter slot (ENERGY STAR).
Signs of leaky ducts
ENERGY STAR says that when rooms run too hot or cold, inadequate air sealing could be the issue, as could insufficient insulation (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says humidity problems or excessive dust may come from ductwork that leaks or is poorly insulated (ENERGY STAR). The flyer's list of common duct problems includes leaky, torn or disconnected ducts, poorly sealed registers, leaks at the furnace, and flexible ducts with kinks (ENERGY STAR). DOE says leaky heating ducts in a vented attic in a cold climate can melt snow on the roof, and that can start ice dams (DOE). DOE warns that icicles can fall on people from those ice dams (DOE).
Sealing ducts yourself or with a contractor
ENERGY STAR's flyer gives a do-it-yourself approach: inspect the ducts you can see, then close accessible leaks and holes with mastic or metal-backed foil tape (ENERGY STAR). For hidden air leaks in the home, the heating and cooling guide says you can hire a contractor who uses special diagnostic tools to pinpoint and seal them (ENERGY STAR). DOE says that repairing concealed ducts can be difficult, and that a qualified professional should seal and insulate them (DOE). The flyer notes that equipment contractors who heat and cool homes often also repair ductwork (ENERGY STAR).
What a contractor does
ENERGY STAR says a contractor should check the entire duct network, including attic and basement spaces and any crawlspace (ENERGY STAR). The contractor should also evaluate supply and return air balance, and many systems have return ducts that are too small (ENERGY STAR). Repair work listed includes damaged, disconnected or undersized ducts, and flexible ducts that are tangled or crushed (ENERGY STAR). Listed sealing materials are mastic, metal tape, and aerosol-based sealant, applied to leaks and connections (ENERGY STAR). Gaps behind registers and grills, where a duct meets a floor, wall or ceiling, should be sealed (ENERGY STAR). Diagnostic tools can be used to check air flow once repairs are finished (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says any duct system improvement should include a new filter (ENERGY STAR). The flyer says a professional should check that the system is balanced once ducts are sealed and insulated (ENERGY STAR).
Insulating ducts after sealing
ENERGY STAR says to wrap ducts that go through unconditioned spaces, such as attics, basements, crawlspaces or garages, so they do not get hot in summer or cold in winter (ENERGY STAR). For ducts in unconditioned areas, the insulation level ENERGY STAR gives is an R-value of 6 or higher (ENERGY STAR). DOE says ducts should be insulated where they run through unheated or uncooled spaces, such as an attic or crawlspace (DOE). DOE adds that R-value may be printed on existing duct insulation (DOE). DOE says wet, smelly or visibly moldy duct insulation needs removal, and a qualified contractor should do the replacement (DOE).
How LBNL tested the sealants
The paper's baking test put a sealed standard duct joint in an oven at temperatures typical of a hot attic, usually 140F to 180F (LBNL). Temperatures were kept under 200F, since some tapes are rated to that temperature (LBNL). The paper's cycling test on a few aerosol-sealed leaks used heated air, a cycle time of about 20 minutes, and about 200 Pa of pressure (LBNL). The paper says the cycling apparatus could not reach cold temperatures that might occur in winter or in air conditioning supply ducts (LBNL). The aging test targeted a six-minute cycle to speed up aging (LBNL). Half of the test sections carried hot air while the other half carried cold air (LBNL). The paper lists design targets: a maximum hot-surface temperature that should match the hottest attic while staying under 200F, and a minimum surface temperature cold enough to form condensation (LBNL).
Which products failed and which held
In the aging test, one duct tape product lasted the full three months, while eleven others failed within days, some falling right off the joint (LBNL, 1998). The article says mastics and aerosol sealant, along with foil-backed and clear tapes, formed good seals for the test period, though these lacked strength (LBNL, 1998). In the paper, virtually all the cloth tape samples in the aging test failed, while some cloth tapes from the baking tests did not (LBNL). The paper says most baked duct tape samples had delaminated, and that heat seemingly caused the rubber adhesive to harden at room temperature (LBNL). The paper says some baked cloth tape samples hardened and kept their seal like a mastic, but because that happened with no pressure applied, it is unlikely that cloth tape would keep sealing that way in a real duct (LBNL). In both the aging and baking tests, duct tapes were the only sealants that failed, and they were the majority of the products tested (LBNL, 1998). In a program undertaken for the EPA, aerosol-sealed ducts were run through hot-air cycles at twice typical duct-system pressures, about every 20 minutes, for two years, and the article reports that duct tightness did not change significantly (LBNL, 1998). Walker says he thinks heat degrades the glue, though he says they can't prove it yet (LBNL, 1998).
What the sealants are
LBNL describes packing tape as typically clear, with a polyester backing and an acrylic adhesive (LBNL). LBNL says packing tape usually has low tensile strength unless it is fiber reinforced (LBNL). LBNL says factory-assembled duct systems often use packing tape (LBNL). LBNL describes foil tape as metal foil backing with an acrylic adhesive, and says it is often seen on rigid systems such as duct board (LBNL). Butyl tape typically has foil backing and a thick butyl adhesive, of 15 to 50 mm, which lets it conform to more irregular shapes (LBNL). LBNL describes aerosol sealant as a sticky vinyl polymer that is pumped through the duct system, where it spans leaks and dries (LBNL). LBNL describes mastic as a wet application that fills gaps, then dries into a soft solid (LBNL). LBNL also notes that field crews dislike mastic, which it describes as messier (LBNL).
Who ran the tests
The paper's authors, Max Sherman and Iain Walker, are in the Energy Performance of Buildings Group at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL). The 1998 article describes Berkeley Lab as a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, located in Berkeley, California (LBNL, 1998). DOE says to make sure ductwork is sealed with mastic instead of ordinary duct tape, in its crawlspace radon guidance (DOE).
Safety check after sealing
ENERGY STAR's flyer lists, among the contractor checks, a combustion safety test once ducts are sealed and a check that gas or oil-burning appliances are not backdrafting (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says leaky ductwork may cause backdrafting, where combustion gases such as carbon monoxide are drawn back into the living space, and that sealing leaks can minimize this risk (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR says a properly sealed and insulated duct system can make a home more comfortable, energy efficient and safe (ENERGY STAR). The flyer adds that particles from insulation, or odors from damp spaces, could make asthma and allergy problems worse (ENERGY STAR).
Frequently asked
Does regular duct tape work to seal ducts?
ENERGY STAR says never to use duct tape, which it says is not long-lasting (ENERGY STAR). DOE says studies show that cloth-backed duct tape fails within months, so the tape should not be used to seal ducts (DOE). The LBNL paper found that fabric-backed tapes with rubber adhesives failed more rapidly than other duct sealants (LBNL).
Is mastic better than foil tape?
The sources name both. ENERGY STAR lists mastic sealant or metal (foil) tape for sealing leaks (ENERGY STAR). If a joint must stay accessible, DOE recommends aluminum foil tape (DOE). DOE also names mastic for seams and joints, and LBNL says field crews dislike mastic, which it describes as messier (LBNL).
Can a homeowner seal ducts without a contractor?
ENERGY STAR's flyer describes a do-it-yourself approach: inspect the ducts you can see, such as in the basement, attic and garage, and seal accessible leaks with mastic or metal-backed foil tape (ENERGY STAR). For ducts hidden in walls or attics, DOE says repairs can be difficult and that a qualified professional should do the sealing and insulating (DOE).
Do ducts need insulation after sealing?
ENERGY STAR says to wrap ducts through unconditioned space with duct insulation rated at an R-value of 6 or higher (ENERGY STAR). DOE says ducts in unheated or uncooled spaces, like an attic or crawlspace, should be insulated, and that R-value may be printed on existing insulation (DOE).
Do I need to call a pro for this?
Maybe. ENERGY STAR notes that hidden ducts in walls, ceilings, attics and basements are tricky to repair (ENERGY STAR). DOE notes that concealed ducts are difficult to repair, so a qualified professional should do the sealing and insulating (DOE). ENERGY STAR says a contractor should look over the whole duct network, attic, basement and crawlspace included (ENERGY STAR).
Related
- Duct Sealing vs Duct Repair: What's the Difference?
- Ductwork Insulation: What Fits Your Home
- Ductwork in Florida: Leaks, Airflow and Installation
- Ducts that sweat: moisture and condensation
Questions about a specific system can go to Blume Mechanical Service at (727) 330-9131.
Sources: ENERGY STAR, Duct Sealing flyer, https://www.energystar.gov/sites/default/files/asset/document/ES_Duct_Sealing_flyer.pdf · ENERGY STAR, Heating and Cooling guide, https://www.energystar.gov/sites/default/files/asset/document/HeatingCoolingGuide%20FINAL_9-4-09_0.pdf · DOE, Insulation guide, https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2013/11/f5/insulation_guide.pdf · LBNL, Max Sherman and Iain Walker, Can Duct-Tape Take the Heat? (LBNL-41434), https://eta-publications.lbl.gov/sites/default/files/lbnl-41434.pdf · LBNL, HVAC: Anything But Duct Tape (article dated August 17, 1998), https://www2.lbl.gov/Science-Articles/Archive/duct-tape-HVAC.html