HVAC, explained
How to Tell if an AC Compressor Is Bad
Carrier lists these signs of a failing air conditioner compressor: the fan runs but the air is not cold, grinding, squealing or banging noises, higher cooling bills, frequent breaker trips, and an outdoor unit that feels excessively hot or shuts down early, which may mean the compressor is failing (Carrier compressor page). Carrier also lists visible refrigerant leaks and ice buildup on the outdoor unit as clear indicators of compressor failure (Carrier compressor page).
Carrier lists warm air from the vents, loud grinding or rattling, frequent short cycling and tripped breakers among bad-compressor symptoms (Carrier compressor page). Lukewarm air and rapid short cycling are signs Carrier lists for a failing capacitor (Carrier capacitor page).
What the compressor does
Lennox places the compressor in the outdoor unit, where it moves refrigerant to carry heat between the indoor and outdoor units (Lennox). Carrier describes it as the central part that circulates refrigerant for heat exchange and cooling of the home (Carrier compressor page). Carrier also says the compressor often sets the efficiency and lifespan of the whole system (Carrier compressor page). Carrier says a compressor typically lasts 10 to 15 years (Carrier compressor page).
Signs the compressor itself is failing
Carrier says that if you notice these warning signs, action is needed right away (Carrier compressor page). The first sign on Carrier's list is no cool air while the fan is running, which may mean refrigerant is not circulating properly (Carrier compressor page). Carrier says grinding, squealing or banging noises often point to mechanical trouble inside the compressor, and lists rattling noises alongside grinding (Carrier compressor page). Carrier notes that a struggling compressor works harder, which can show up as higher cooling bills (Carrier compressor page). Carrier says frequent breaker trips can mean the compressor is running hot or drawing too much power (Carrier compressor page). Carrier also treats visible refrigerant leaks and ice on the outdoor unit as clear signs of failure (Carrier compressor page). Lennox describes a matching case where the outdoor fan runs with no cool air, while power reaches the unit and the compressor does not engage (Lennox). Lennox ties repeated breaker trips to an electrical fault linked to the compressor's power draw (Lennox). Lennox says a breaker that keeps tripping after a reset signals an electrical problem for a professional to investigate, and that a compressor replacement may be needed (Lennox).
Overheating and shutdowns
Lennox says a compressor can overheat during extremely hot weather or after long heavy use, which can trip its internal thermal overload protection (Lennox). Lennox calls that shutdown temporary until the unit cools, and says repeat shutdowns point to an underlying issue worth looking into (Lennox). If the compressor shuts off from overheating, Lennox says to wait 30 minutes before restarting (Lennox). Lennox also says low refrigerant can make the compressor stop itself as a protective measure (Lennox). Lennox says long-term electrical strain or mechanical wear may lead to compressor failure, and adds that this is the most significant repair scenario (Lennox).
Signs of a failing capacitor
Lennox says a failed capacitor often sounds like clicking or humming while the system struggles to start (Lennox). Carrier says a humming outdoor unit usually means the motor is trying to start without enough torque from the capacitor (Carrier capacitor page). Trane, writing about heat pumps, says a bad capacitor may make a clicking sound every few seconds, which you can hear by standing beside the outdoor unit (Trane). Trane, writing about heat pumps, says a failed start capacitor may also bring a loud hum from the motor (Trane). Carrier says a weak capacitor may be behind lukewarm air, and lists rapid short cycling and higher energy use as signs (Carrier capacitor page). Trane, writing about heat pumps, says that if the unit is running but its fan is not spinning, that can be a sign of a bad capacitor (Trane). Carrier says a capacitor may appear swollen or show an oil leak (Carrier capacitor page), and Trane lists bulging, cracks and oozing liquid as visible signs of a failed capacitor (Trane). Trane says overheating is the biggest reason a capacitor fails, while years of wear or a long run during a heat wave can also cause failure (Trane).
How the sources tell the two apart
Carrier says grinding, squealing or banging often points to mechanical trouble inside the compressor (Carrier compressor page). Carrier says a humming outdoor unit usually points to a capacitor that cannot supply enough torque to the motor (Carrier capacitor page). Trane, writing about heat pumps, says that when the compressor and fan both run, the trouble lies elsewhere and not with the capacitor (Trane). Carrier warns that a failing capacitor can strain the compressor and fan motors (Carrier capacitor page). Carrier says running with a bad capacitor can permanently damage those motors (Carrier capacitor page). Carrier also says replacing the capacitor right away is cheaper than replacing the compressor later (Carrier capacitor page).
Safety and who should do the work
Carrier strongly recommends homeowners do not try replacing a capacitor on their own (Carrier capacitor page). Carrier also warns that a capacitor can hold high-voltage electricity that poses serious injury or death risk even with the power disconnected (Carrier capacitor page). Carrier says testing a capacitor takes specialized tools, because these parts can hold a lethal charge even with power off (Carrier capacitor page). Carrier describes a technician cutting power to the unit to prevent electrocution (Carrier capacitor page). Trane says only a trained HVAC professional should test, discharge or replace a capacitor, and that replacing one is not a DIY job (Trane). Lennox says a technician handles capacitor replacement (Lennox), and that capacitors, contactors and wiring need specialized tools and expertise to diagnose safely (Lennox). Lennox says a licensed technician must do the refrigerant diagnosis and repair (Lennox). Carrier says a compressor swap needs special tools and hazardous refrigerant handling, and calls it not a DIY task (Carrier compressor page).
Checks a homeowner can make
Lennox says to check that the thermostat is set to Cool, with the setpoint below room temperature, and that the batteries are not dead (Lennox). Trane says to make sure the thermostat is in Cool mode or Heat mode, with the temperature set above or below the indoor temperature (Trane). Lennox says a clogged filter limits airflow and can strain the compressor along with the rest of the system (Lennox). Trane says clogged air filters can lead to many problems (Trane). Lennox says to clear leaves, dirt and overgrowth from around the outdoor unit, because they restrict airflow and can cause overheating (Lennox). Carrier says to keep the outdoor unit unobstructed so air can flow and keep internal components cool (Carrier capacitor page). Lennox says a professional should remove any debris found inside the equipment (Lennox).
Frequently asked
Do I need to call a pro for this?
Yes. Lennox says to call a licensed HVAC professional if the simple checks do not bring the system back (Lennox). Refrigerant work and electrical work such as capacitor, contactor and wiring checks should go to a licensed contractor (Lennox). Lennox's no-tools checks include a thermostat check and clearing debris near the outdoor unit (Lennox).
How can I tell a bad capacitor from a bad compressor by sound?
Lennox ties clicking or humming from an outdoor unit that never fully starts to a struggling capacitor or motor (Lennox). Trane says a bad capacitor may click every few seconds (Trane). Carrier says grinding, squealing or banging often points to mechanical trouble inside the compressor (Carrier compressor page).
Can I run the AC with a bad capacitor?
Carrier recommends not running an air conditioner once its capacitor is bad (Carrier capacitor page). Carrier also says that running one can permanently harm the compressor and the fan motors (Carrier capacitor page).
Can I replace an AC capacitor myself?
Carrier strongly recommends homeowners do not try replacing a capacitor on their own (Carrier capacitor page). Trane says replacing a heat pump capacitor is not a DIY job (Trane).
How long does an AC compressor last?
Carrier says a compressor typically lasts 10 to 15 years (Carrier compressor page). Lennox says that if a compressor reaches 10 to 15 years, or repair costs keep piling up, a full system replacement deserves serious thought (Lennox).
Related
- AC Capacitor and Fan Failures: What the Parts Do and Who Should Replace Them
- AC Compressor Problems: Turning On and Off, and a Bad Compressor
- AC Not Turning On: What to Check Before You Call
- AC Noises Decoded: Buzzing, Humming, Hissing, and Rattling
- How to Clean an Air Conditioner Filter
Questions about a specific system can go to Blume Mechanical Service at (727) 330-9131.
Sources: Carrier, What Is an AC Compressor?, https://www.carrier.com/us/en/residential/hvac-resources/air-conditioners/ac-compressor/ · Carrier, Understanding AC Capacitors: Cost, Signs of Failure and Replacement, https://www.carrier.com/us/en/residential/hvac-resources/air-conditioners/ac-capacitor/ · Lennox, Why Is My AC Compressor Not Turning On?, https://www.lennox.com/residential/lennox-life/consumer/ac-compressor-not-turning-on · Trane, All About Heat Pump Capacitors and Signs of Trouble, https://www.trane.com/residential/en/resources/troubleshooting/heat-pumps/heat-pump-capacitor/