Blume Mechanical ServiceBlumeMechanical Service

HVAC, explained

How to Choose a Heating and Air Conditioning System

Carrier says a heat pump or an air conditioner choice is often shaped by climate and heating needs (Carrier heat pump vs AC). Trane points to a Manual J calculation as the way to find the unit size, in BTUs of heating and cooling a home needs (Trane sizing).

Lennox names three main types of system: split-system, ductless and packaged units (Lennox sizing). Carrier says a furnace burns fuel to make heat, while a heat pump moves heat from outside air into the home (Carrier heat pump vs furnace).

Pick the system type for your climate

Carrier says a furnace needs a separate air conditioner for cooling, while a heat pump provides heating and cooling in one unit (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Carrier says a heat pump can run in reverse to provide heat, while an air conditioner only cools (Carrier heat pump vs AC). Bryant says a high-efficiency heat pump is, in general, a very flexible pick for moderate climates (Bryant). Bryant says a furnace or boiler will be essential in cold climates (Bryant). Trane says a heat pump with an air handler is most suitable for mild to moderate climates, and a variable-speed model can provide heating down to 17 degrees Fahrenheit (Trane heat pump vs AC). Carrier says its cold-climate heat pump, the 27VNA1, can provide heating down to -23°F (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Carrier says a dual fuel system uses the heat pump on milder days and the furnace when temperatures plunge (Carrier heat pump vs furnace).

Size the unit before comparing models

Trane says a Manual J calculation accounts for square footage, climate zone, windows, shade, insulation, occupants and heat-generating appliances (Trane sizing). Lennox says the Manual J process also takes ductwork into account, as one of several factors (Lennox sizing). Lennox calls a square footage calculation a rough idea, and says many other factors can affect a home's true BTUh rating (Lennox sizing). Lennox gives a rough formula: multiply total square footage by 20 to get a BTUh rating, then divide by 12,000 to get tons (Lennox sizing). Trane says one ton of cooling equals 12,000 BTUs per hour (Trane sizing). Trane says that if the BTU need falls between two sizes, go with the bigger unit (Trane sizing). Lennox says bigger isn't always better (Lennox sizing). Bryant says an oversized system can short cycle, turning on and off too frequently and wasting energy (Bryant). Lennox says an undersized unit can run constantly, raising utility bills (Lennox sizing).

Compare ratings and noise

Bryant says cooling is rated by SEER2 and EER2, and heating by HSPF2 for heat pumps or AFUE for furnaces (Bryant). Bryant says a higher rating means a more energy-efficient system (Bryant). Lennox says most common systems rate between 14 and 16 SEER2, while high-efficiency systems can reach 22 SEER2 (Lennox sizing). Carrier says the 27VNA1 cold-climate heat pump delivers up to 12.5 HSPF2 (Carrier heat pump vs AC). Carrier says heat pumps and air conditioners typically sound alike when cooling, but heat pumps also run in winter (Carrier heat pump vs AC).

Compare costs, lifespan and upkeep

Carrier says a heat pump often costs more up front for its outdoor unit than an air conditioner, but it can make a separate furnace unnecessary in many climates (Carrier heat pump vs AC). Trane says a new heat pump system may need ductwork or electrical panel upgrades that add to the upfront cost (Trane heat pump vs AC). Carrier says heat pumps typically last about 10 to 15 years and gas furnaces about 15 to 20 years, in its general comparison (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Trane says a central air conditioner can last about 15 years with proper maintenance, and a heat pump 12 to 15 years (Trane heat pump vs AC). Trane says an AC unit should get service each spring, and a heat pump should get service in spring and fall (Trane heat pump vs AC). Bryant says a warranty covers parts, and in some cases labor, for an extended period (Bryant). Carrier says operating cost depends on local electricity and gas prices, climate, and how the equipment is sized (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Carrier says no single system has the lowest operating cost in every home (Carrier heat pump vs furnace).

Installation, safety and upkeep

Lennox says to choose a qualified installation professional once the size and system type are settled (Lennox sizing). Trane says improper sizing or poor installation will leave a home less comfortable than it should be (Trane heat pump vs AC). Carrier says gas furnaces burn fuel, so proper venting and working safety controls are important for reducing risks from combustion gases, including carbon monoxide (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Carrier says both systems are safe when properly maintained (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Carrier says regular checks by a qualified HVAC technician matter for safety (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Carrier says clearance varies by model, and homeowners should follow the manufacturer's instructions and local codes (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Trane lists regular air filter changes and a clear outdoor unit as homeowner maintenance (Trane heat pump vs AC).

Frequently asked

Do I need to call a pro for this?

Yes. Lennox says a square footage calculation gives a rough idea, and suggests a professional energy audit (Lennox sizing). For refrigerant, electrical, gas, combustion or venting work, use a licensed contractor. Between visits, a homeowner can check the air filter and keep the outdoor unit clear, as Trane lists (Trane heat pump vs AC).

Is a heat pump better than a furnace?

Carrier says the better choice depends on climate. Carrier says heat pumps are generally more efficient and provide heating and cooling together, which suits moderate climates (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Carrier says furnaces are typically better suited to steady high-temperature heat where winters are severe (Carrier heat pump vs furnace).

Can a heat pump replace an air conditioner?

Carrier says yes, a heat pump can replace an air conditioner and also adds heating (Carrier heat pump vs AC).

Do heat pumps really save money?

Carrier says in many cases, yes. Carrier says heat pumps move heat rather than generate it, so they can run far more efficiently than traditional electric or fuel-based heat (Carrier heat pump vs AC). Carrier says savings depend on local climate and the system being replaced (Carrier heat pump vs AC).

At what temperature does a heat pump struggle?

Carrier says older heat pumps often struggle below 25 to 30 °F (Carrier heat pump vs furnace). Carrier says its newer cold climate models are designed to keep heating efficiently in outdoor temperatures as low as -22°F (Carrier heat pump vs furnace).

Related

Questions about a specific system can go to Blume Mechanical Service at (727) 330-9131.

Sources: Bryant, guide to choosing the right HVAC system for your home, https://www.bryant.com/en/us/products/best-hvac-systems/ · Trane, What Size HVAC Unit Do I Need?, https://www.trane.com/residential/en/resources/blog/size-hvac-unit-need/ · Lennox, What Size AC Unit Do I Need?, https://www.lennox.com/residential/lennox-life/consumer/what-size-ac-unit-do-i-need · Carrier, Heat Pump vs. Air Conditioner: Which is Right for You?, https://www.carrier.com/us/en/residential/hvac-resources/heat-pumps/heat-pump-vs-air-conditioner/ · Trane, Heat Pump vs Air Conditioner: Which One Is Right for You, https://www.trane.com/residential/en/resources/blog/heat-pump-vs-air-conditioner/ · Carrier, Heat Pump vs Furnace: Which System is Right for You?, https://www.carrier.com/us/en/residential/hvac-resources/furnaces/electric-heat-pump-vs-furnace/

Search Google for how to choose heating and air conditioning system