Blume Mechanical ServiceBlumeMechanical Service

HVAC, explained

How to compare heating fuel costs per Btu

Heating fuels are sold in different units, so compare them by cost based on heat content, such as dollars per million Btu (EIA). EIA says published heating oil and propane prices are only a general guide for prices in your area (EIA). Confirm the price you actually pay with your fuel supplier.

Gallons, cubic feet, therms and kilowatthours cannot be compared directly. This guide explains the method the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) describes for comparing heating fuel costs, and what EIA's published prices do and do not show. Each fact names its source. For a bill or a fuel contract, check the numbers with your supplier or utility.

Why fuels cannot be compared by unit price

Heating fuels are sold in different units, such as gallons of oil and propane, cubic feet or therms of natural gas, and kilowatthours of electricity (EIA). Comparing the price of fuels in those dissimilar units is not meaningful (EIA).

In the United States, Btu is the most common unit for comparing energy sources or fuels (EIA). The Btu content of fuels varies slightly from country to country because fuels come from different places (EIA).

Use the same unit on both sides before you compare anything. Write each price in dollars per unit next to the Btu content of that unit.

Cost per million Btu

A more useful comparison is the cost of fuels based on their heat content, such as dollars per million British thermal units (Btu) (EIA). Consumers may want to compare the cost of different heating fuels and energy sources when choosing a heating system (EIA).

For winter comparisons, EIA divides the average natural gas and heating oil monthly prices per unit by the Btu content of each fuel, expressed in million Btu (EIA).

Cost per Btu is one input

EIA describes a cost-per-Btu comparison as more useful than comparing prices in different units (EIA). Cost per Btu is one input to a heating decision, and it does not settle the choice by itself. Ask a licensed technician to review the heating equipment you have before you change fuels.

Keep your own records of each bill, including the unit, the total and the billing period, so you compare like with like.

What heating oil is and where it is used

Heating oil is sold mainly for boilers and furnaces for space heating, and for water heaters (EIA). Nearly all heating oil consumed in the United States is produced from crude oil (EIA).

Ask your supplier what product and blend you are buying before you compare prices.

What the published prices are

The price you are being charged for heating oil or propane can vary widely from the prices that EIA publishes (EIA). EIA publishes the averages of the heating oil and propane prices that survey respondents report (EIA).

The published prices do not include taxes, premiums, or any discounts that a supplier may charge or offer (EIA). The heating oil and propane prices EIA publishes are only a general guide for prices in your area (EIA).

What EIA cannot judge

EIA cannot say whether a heating oil or propane price is reasonable or fair, because those prices are not regulated (EIA). If you think a heating oil or propane supplier is charging unfairly, you can contact your local Better Business Bureau chapter or your state consumer protection agency, usually administered by the Attorney General (EIA).

Compare quotes from more than one supplier, and get the price and terms in writing before you sign.

The winter price outlook

EIA publishes a forecast for residential heating fuel prices in the October through March editions of its Short-Term Energy Outlook (EIA). The forecast covers households heating with natural gas, heating oil, propane, and electricity, at a national and regional level (EIA). This is a national and regional outlook, so it does not give a single price for your home (EIA).

The forecast for each winter is first featured in the Winter Fuels Outlook in the October edition of the Short-Term Energy Outlook (EIA). Read it as a national and regional outlook, then check your own supplier's current price.

Check your equipment and your bills

EIA winter comparisons cover the months from October through March (EIA). Gather your last twelve months of fuel bills, with the unit and total on each. Convert each price to dollars per million Btu before you compare two fuels, and check the Btu content with your supplier.

If your heating system needs a check before you decide on a fuel, a licensed technician can inspect it. Blume Mechanical Service repairs, installs and maintains HVAC and refrigeration equipment in Pinellas, Hillsborough and Pasco counties.

Frequently asked

Why compare heating fuels per Btu?

Heating fuels are sold in different units, so comparing prices in those units is not meaningful (EIA). A more useful comparison is cost based on heat content, such as dollars per million Btu (EIA). The method compares heat content, not the unit a fuel is sold in (EIA).

Are the heating oil prices EIA publishes my price?

The price you are being charged can vary widely from the prices that EIA publishes (EIA). Published prices do not include taxes, premiums, or supplier discounts (EIA). Keep your invoices and delivery tickets as your own record.

Can EIA say whether my propane price is fair?

EIA cannot say whether a heating oil or propane price is reasonable or fair, because those prices are not regulated (EIA).

Where can I file a complaint about a fuel supplier?

You can contact your local Better Business Bureau chapter or your state consumer protection agency, usually administered by the Attorney General (EIA). Keep copies of the invoices in question.

Is there a winter heating fuel price forecast?

EIA publishes a winter forecast in the October through March editions of its Short-Term Energy Outlook (EIA). The forecast covers natural gas, heating oil, propane and electricity (EIA).

What is heating oil made from?

Nearly all heating oil consumed in the United States is produced from crude oil (EIA). Heating oil is sold mainly for boilers and furnaces for space heating, and for water heaters (EIA).

Related

Need a heating system check before you decide on a fuel? Blume Mechanical Service (license CAC-1822618) repairs, installs and maintains HVAC and refrigeration equipment in Pinellas, Hillsborough and Pasco counties. Call 727-330-9131.

Sources: U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) — How do I compare the cost of heating fuels? (https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=987&t=7) · U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) — Why am I being charged more for heating oil or propane than the price on EIA's website? (https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=169&t=8) · U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) — What can I expect to pay for heating this winter? (https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=867&t=8) · U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) — Energy units and calculators (https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/units-and-calculators/) · U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) — Heating oil (https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/heating-oil/)

Search Google for compare heating fuel costs