HVAC, explained
What R-6 and R-8 Duct Insulation Mean and Where Each Is Called For
ENERGY STAR calls for R-6 or higher duct insulation on ducts in unconditioned areas such as attics, crawlspaces and garages (ENERGY STAR). DOE's guide reports that the 2009 IECC recommends R-8 for supply ducts in attics and R-6 for other ducts, with no minimum for ducts completely within the building's thermal envelope (DOE).
DOE names attics and crawlspaces as unheated or uncooled spaces where ducts should be insulated (DOE). ENERGY STAR names attics, crawlspaces and garages as unconditioned areas where ducts need insulation (ENERGY STAR).
What an existing R-value tells you
DOE notes that older homes usually have sheet metal ducts, and that newer homes often have ducts with built-in insulation (DOE). According to DOE, ducts that pass through an unheated or uncooled space, like an attic, should be insulated (DOE). The R-value may be printed on the insulation already on the ducts (DOE). DOE's guide recommends more insulation on ducts that already have some when their R-value falls below 4.2, a figure it credits to LBNL 2003 (DOE). Compressed insulation loses R-value, so the tape on a wrap should be applied without squeezing the insulation (DOE).
Where R-8 and R-6 are called for
Per DOE, the 2009 IECC's recommendation is R-8 as a minimum for supply ducts in attics and R-6 as a minimum for other ducts (DOE). DOE gives this as the 2009 IECC figure, citing section 403.2.1 (DOE). No minimum applies, per the same DOE passage, to ducts entirely inside the thermal envelope under the 2009 IECC (DOE). ENERGY STAR's flyer sets a figure of R-6 or higher for ducts in unconditioned areas, which it lists as attics, crawlspaces and garages (ENERGY STAR).
Ducts inside the conditioned space
DOE says supply ducts inside conditioned space should get insulation so moisture does not gather on the duct, on the interior in summer and the exterior in winter (DOE). Exhaust ducts that run through cold spaces in winter should also be insulated to prevent condensation inside them (DOE). DOE says insulating ducts in an unconditioned basement or crawlspace makes that space colder, and water pipes there may freeze and burst in a cold climate (DOE).
Sealing before the wrap goes on
ENERGY STAR's sealing page says to start by sealing air leaks with mastic or metal tape, and then to insulate all the ducts you can access, including ones in the attic, crawlspace, unfinished basement and garage (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR also says to never use duct tape, which is not long-lasting (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR notes that many homeowners hire a contractor for duct improvement work, and that most heating and cooling contractors also repair ductwork (ENERGY STAR). ENERGY STAR's flyer adds that registers and grills need a tight seal where they meet the ducts (ENERGY STAR). Once sealing is done, DOE says the ducts should get a fiberglass wrap whose foil or vinyl facing sits on the outside (DOE).
How the wrap is installed
DOE describes a method: fiberglass wrap with a foil or vinyl face, the vapor retarder pointing outward, and full coverage of each duct (DOE). The facings should overlap where pieces meet and be sealed with fiberglass tape, applied carefully so the insulation is not squeezed (DOE). ENERGY STAR's flyer advises wrapping ducts that cross unconditioned space like attics, basements, crawlspaces or garages (ENERGY STAR).
Checks after the work
DOE says a qualified heating and cooling system contractor should handle swapping out wrap that is soggy, smelling or moldy (DOE). DOE also says the contractor will evaluate airflow and run a combustion safety test after the work is done (DOE). ENERGY STAR's flyer says a contractor should check airflow once repairs finish, and says to rule out backdrafting of gas or oil-burning appliances (ENERGY STAR). After sealing and insulating, ENERGY STAR's flyer says a professional should check that the system is balanced (ENERGY STAR).
Frequently asked
What R-value do ducts in an attic need?
DOE's guide reports that the 2009 IECC recommends R-8 as the minimum for supply ducts in attics (DOE). ENERGY STAR's flyer calls for R-6 or higher insulation on ducts in unconditioned areas, which include attics (ENERGY STAR).
What R-value do other ducts need under the 2009 IECC?
DOE reports that the 2009 IECC gives R-6 as the minimum for other ducts (DOE). DOE also reports no minimum under that code for ducts entirely inside the thermal envelope (DOE).
Do ducts inside the conditioned space need insulation?
DOE's guide says to insulate supply ducts in conditioned space so that condensation is avoided, which it places inside the duct in summer and outside it in winter (DOE). DOE's guide says exhaust ducts through cold spaces in winter should also be insulated (DOE).
When is adding insulation recommended for existing ducts?
DOE's guide says adding insulation is recommended if the existing R-value is less than 4.2, citing LBNL 2003 (DOE). DOE also says ducts should be insulated when they run through unheated or uncooled spaces, such as an attic or crawlspace (DOE).
Do I need to call a pro for this?
Maybe. DOE's guide says a qualified heating and cooling system contractor should handle soggy, smelling or moldy duct wrap (DOE). ENERGY STAR's flyer says a contractor should check airflow after repairs (ENERGY STAR). For any combustion or venting check, such as testing for backdrafting of gas or oil-burning appliances, use a licensed contractor. Homeowner checks you can make are the air filter, thermostat settings, and clearing things away from vents, returns and the outdoor unit.
Related
- Ductwork Insulation: What Fits Your Home
- Ductwork in Florida: Leaks, Airflow and Installation
- Ducts that sweat: moisture and condensation
- Duct Sealing vs Duct Repair: What's the Difference?
Questions about a specific system can go to Blume Mechanical Service at (727) 330-9131.
Sources: U.S. Department of Energy, Insulation guide (PDF, 138 pages), https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2013/11/f5/insulation_guide.pdf · ENERGY STAR, Duct Sealing flyer (PDF, 2 pages), https://www.energystar.gov/sites/default/files/asset/document/ES_Duct_Sealing_flyer.pdf · ENERGY STAR, Duct Sealing, https://www.energystar.gov/saveathome/heating-cooling/duct-sealing