HVAC, explained
Does an Air Purifier Help With Smells?
A portable air cleaner can remove odors and gases when it has an activated carbon filter or another filter designed to remove gases (EPA guide). EPA says an air-cleaning device built around particle removal has no control over gases and some odors (EPA summary).
EPA says some pollutants in indoor air are particles and others are gases, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are among the gases (EPA guide).
Particles and gases need different filters
EPA says most filters target either particles or gases (EPA guide). Many air cleaners that handle both pair a particle filter with a second filter for gases, including some gases that have odors (EPA guide). Gas-phase filters remove gases and odors through physical or chemical processes, and EPA names a sorbent such as activated carbon as the material that adsorbs the pollutants (EPA summary). EPA names activated carbon as the most common adsorbent in HVAC systems and portable cleaners (EPA summary). Gas-phase filters are aimed at a few gaseous pollutants, so they will not reduce pollutants they were not designed for (EPA summary). EPA expects no gas-phase filter to remove every gaseous pollutant in a typical home (EPA summary). EPA says gas-phase filters are far less common in homes than particle filters, and one reason may be that a gas-phase filter can become overloaded quickly (EPA summary).
What a portable cleaner can and cannot do with gases
For gases, EPA says to pick a portable air cleaner that has an activated carbon filter or another gas-removing filter (EPA guide). EPA says activated carbon filters can be effective when the filter holds a large amount of material (EPA guide). EPA also says there is no widely used rating system for portable cleaners or filters designed for gases (EPA guide). The CADR rating is for particles only (EPA guide). Portable cleaners often reach a high CADR with a HEPA filter (EPA guide). A unit with a high CADR and a carbon filter can handle both particles and gases, EPA says (EPA guide). EPA says research has not yet shown that plasma, photocatalytic oxidation or ultraviolet light can remove gases effectively in portable home cleaners (EPA guide). EPA says photocatalytic oxidation cleaners aim to turn gases into harmless products, but current catalysts are ineffective against indoor gases (EPA summary). EPA says that with a device built only to remove particles, tobacco smoke odor and many of its gas-phase pollutants stay in the air (EPA summary).
VOCs and the smells from products
EPA describes VOCs as gases given off by certain solids and liquids (EPA VOCs). EPA says many VOCs are human-made chemicals used in paints, pharmaceuticals and refrigerants (EPA VOCs). EPA says a wide variety of products, numbering in the thousands, give off VOCs (EPA VOCs). EPA says indoor levels of many VOCs are consistently higher, up to ten times, than outdoor levels (EPA VOCs). EPA lists tobacco smoke, building materials, and products such as paints, adhesives, solvents, cleaners, deodorizers and pesticides as sources of airborne gaseous organic compounds (EPA summary). An MIT study of consumer-grade cleaners that use chemical oxidation found they can be a source of VOCs themselves (MIT). In the study, only two of the four products removed both test gases, toluene and limonene, after 60 to 90 minutes in a chamber (MIT). MIT reports that the chemical reactions played a minor role, and that absorbent materials and filters did most of the removal (MIT). MIT also reports that the cleaners themselves emitted hundreds of compounds, including formaldehyde and acetone, through slow outgassing (MIT). The MIT researchers write that VOC removal may be minimal for some consumer-grade portable cleaners, and that delivered air may hold extra VOCs or oxidation byproducts (MIT). The researchers also note that these products are not regulated, and that few data exist on their VOC removal rates (MIT). MIT quotes professor Jesse Kroll saying that activated carbon filtering, which does not rely on chemical reactions, "is still the way to go" (MIT).
Ozone and what to avoid
EPA says avoid any portable cleaner or HVAC filter built to make ozone on purpose (EPA guide). EPA says ozone generators sold as air cleaners intentionally make the gas ozone (EPA guide). EPA says ozone is a lung irritant (EPA guide). EPA notes that electronic cleaners may produce ozone either on purpose or as a by-product (EPA summary). EPA says electronic air cleaners remove small particles, but they do not remove gases or odors (EPA summary).
Mold and musty smells
EPA says air cleaners and furnace or HVAC filters do not fix the cause of mold and musty smells (EPA guide). EPA says mold grows where there is a water problem, so the fix is to get rid of the moisture source and clean up the mold (EPA guide). EPA says in some cases air cleaners may help reduce mold odors, but they will not fix the moisture behind the mold (EPA guide). EPA says air cleaners may remove some of the particles that mold generates (EPA guide).
Combustion gases and the limits of air cleaning
EPA describes gaseous pollutants as including combustion gases and organic chemicals not bound to particles (EPA summary). EPA lists combustion appliances, tobacco smoke and vehicle exhaust from attached garages among sources of combustion gases like carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide (EPA summary). EPA lists improperly installed or maintained chimneys and flues among sources of respirable particles (EPA summary). EPA says air cleaners by themselves cannot assure adequate air quality, especially where major sources exist and ventilation is poor (EPA summary). EPA says all filters need regular replacement, and when a filter is dirty and overloaded, it will not work well (EPA guide).
Frequently asked
Which filter removes odors and gases?
EPA points to an activated carbon filter, or another filter designed to remove gases, for a portable air cleaner (EPA guide). EPA says activated carbon is the most common adsorbent in HVAC systems and portable cleaners (EPA summary).
Does a HEPA or particle-rated cleaner remove odors?
Portable cleaners often reach a high CADR with a HEPA filter (EPA guide). EPA says the CADR rating is for particles only, and devices built for particles have no control over gases and some odors (EPA summary).
Do electronic or ionizer cleaners remove odors?
EPA says electronic air cleaners do not remove gases or odors, although they remove small particles (EPA summary). EPA calls ion generators the most basic kind of electronic air cleaner (EPA summary).
Can a cleaner remove VOCs from paint or cleaning products?
In the two cleaners that removed both test VOCs in the MIT chamber tests, the physical or sorbent filters did the bulk of the removal (MIT). EPA says research has not yet shown that plasma, photocatalytic oxidation or ultraviolet light can remove gases effectively in portable home cleaners (EPA guide).
Do I need to call a pro for this?
Maybe. Checking the air filter is one homeowner check, and EPA says all filters need regular replacement (EPA guide). If the smell could come from gas, combustion or venting work, call a licensed contractor.
Related
- CADR ratings: how to choose a portable air cleaner
- How do air purifiers work? A homeowner's guide
- Ozone generators sold as air cleaners: EPA and CARB facts
- VOCs and indoor air quality: EPA's guidance for homes
- What Is a Heat Pump? A Plain Explanation for Homeowners
Questions about a specific system can go to Blume Mechanical Service at (727) 330-9131.
Sources: EPA, Guide to Air Cleaners in the Home, https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/guide-air-cleaners-home · EPA, Residential Air Cleaners (Second Edition): A Summary of Available Information (revised August 2009), https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/residential-air-cleaners-second-edition-summary-available-information_.html · EPA, What are volatile organic compounds (VOCs)?, https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/what-are-volatile-organic-compounds-vocs · MIT News, Study finds indoor air cleaners fall short on removing volatile organic compounds, https://news.mit.edu/2021/study-finds-indoor-air-cleaners-fall-short-removing-volatile-organic-compounds-1029