Blume Mechanical ServiceBlumeMechanical Service

HVAC, explained

Does an Air Purifier Help With Allergies?

Carrier says air purifiers do not treat allergies, but they can filter out airborne allergens such as pet dander, dust and pollen (Carrier). Trane says most experts agree that purifiers can remove particles tied to allergy and asthma symptoms, while an EPA-listed study of 32 healthy adults found that air purification did not significantly improve pulmonary function, with no demonstrable impact on improving health (Trane; EPA).

Carrier says indoor exposure to pet dander and dust mites can trigger allergy and asthma symptoms (Carrier). Bryant names common allergens such as tree, grass and weed pollen, pet dander, dust mites and mold spores (Bryant). Trane says an air cleaner or purifier mainly filters out allergens and particles that may set off allergy and asthma symptoms (Trane).

What the makers say a purifier does

Carrier says in most cases a purifier moves room air through a filter or a series of filters, and that its effectiveness is directly tied to the capability of those filters (Carrier). Carrier says air purifiers can remove allergens such as dust, pollen and pet hair (Carrier). Bryant says a purifier draws in indoor air through filters that capture airborne particles, which can significantly reduce the concentration of common allergens (Bryant). Carrier says electronic models give incoming particles an electrical charge and collect them on oppositely charged plates or filters, and that they often include a mechanical pre-filter that must be replaced regularly (Carrier). Bryant says that consistent removal of allergens can reduce how often and how severely allergy symptoms occur (Bryant).

Filter ratings: HEPA, MERV and CADR

Carrier says true HEPA filters have been verified against particles sized 0.3 microns in diameter (Carrier). Carrier also says HEPA filters are not MERV rated, and that a MERV rating expresses how well a whole-home filter captures airborne particles (Carrier). Bryant says a higher MERV rating means the filter can catch smaller particles, including pollen and pet dander (Bryant). Carrier says the Clean Air Delivery Rate, or CADR, was developed by AHAM to measure how well an air filter works for a room space, based on the amount of clean air it produces each minute (Carrier). Carrier says CADR ratings are recorded for dust, pollen and smoke, which it calls the three most common indoor pollutants (Carrier). Bryant says the CADR should match the dimensions of the room (Bryant). Trane says larger rooms may benefit from a unit with a higher CADR, which indicates cleaner air (Trane).

What the EPA study tested

The EPA-listed study used a randomized crossover design with 32 healthy individuals (EPA). One group used true air purifiers and the other used sham air purifiers for four weeks, and after a four-week washout each group switched (EPA). Researchers measured PM2.5, coarser particulate matter, ozone, pulmonary function and fractional exhaled nitric oxide (EPA). Indoor PM2.5 concentrations decreased with the true air purifiers compared with the sham units, but the decrease was not significant (p = 0.08) (EPA). The air purification did not significantly improve pulmonary function (EPA). The study's conclusion was that air purification slightly improved indoor PM2.5 in ordinary homes, with no demonstrable impact on improving health (EPA). The study is listed as in press (EPA).

Ozone, asthma and product labels

Trane says air purifiers that emit ozone can exacerbate asthma symptoms (Trane). Trane says people with asthma should read product information carefully and look for devices with no or low ozone output (Trane). Trane describes its CleanEffects whole-home air cleaner as having zero ozone emissions (Trane).

Room units, whole-home units and noise

Carrier says a room air purifier is not considered a whole-home solution, while a whole-home unit such as the Carrier Infinity air purifier is tied into the home's HVAC system (Carrier). Carrier says its EZ Flex cabinet is not considered an air purifier but an air filter, and that it can filter household pollutants like dust mites and pollen (Carrier). Trane says a portable purifier's reach is limited to the immediate vicinity, so several rooms may need units for people with severe allergies or asthma (Trane). Trane offers its CleanEffects whole-home air cleaner as one alternative (Trane). Trane says top-quality purifiers with multiple filters make some noise, and the sound depends on the model and setting (Trane). Trane says a larger unit can give quieter operation at lower speeds for people who are noise-sensitive (Trane). Carrier says some of its own models offer several fan speeds, which allow more airflow and filtering or quieter operation if preferred (Carrier).

Running time, filter changes and upkeep

Carrier says an air purifier should ideally run continuously where air quality concerns are significant, and that energy costs and noise levels are also worth weighing (Carrier). Carrier says that running a whole-home unit's fan continuously can mean more frequent filter changes and higher energy use (Carrier). Carrier says many purifier filters need to be replaced every six to 12 months, depending on the filter type and the maker's recommendations (Carrier). Trane says to consider the type of filter, how easy it is to replace, how often it needs replacing and its cost (Trane).

Steps that go along with a purifier

Carrier says the most effective approach includes steps beyond a purifier, such as removing or reducing sources of airborne pollutants, ventilating with kitchen or bathroom exhaust fans and adding filters or purifiers (Carrier). Carrier lists banning indoor smoking, using fireplaces less, running the exhaust fan when cooking, and cleaning heating and air conditioner filters when needed (Carrier). Trane says an air purifier should complement other measures, not replace them, and that essential parts of a holistic approach include daily vacuuming, keeping windows closed and washing clothes and bedding in hot water (Trane).

Frequently asked

What should I look for in an air purifier for allergies?

Carrier says to look for a model with a MERV 15 filter, or one with a HEPA filter (Carrier). For a room unit, Carrier says to consider the CADR so it matches the room size, and to check for AHAM or Energy Star marks for performance and efficiency (Carrier).

Does the EPA-listed study show that air purifiers improve health?

The EPA-listed study of 32 healthy adults found that air purification did not significantly improve pulmonary function, and it found no demonstrable impact on improving health (EPA).

Do I need to call a pro for this?

Maybe. Routine filter care and the thermostat fan setting are homeowner checks. Carrier says to clean the heating and cooling filters when needed, and that continuous fan mode may mean more frequent filter changes (Carrier). Bryant says a professional installation ensures an air purifier operates at peak efficiency (Bryant). For refrigerant, electrical, gas, combustion or venting work, use a licensed contractor.

Does a humidifier help with allergies?

Bryant says a humidifier may ease symptoms caused by dry air, while an air purifier helps remove allergens from the air and a humidifier does not remove allergy-causing particles (Bryant).

Do air purifiers need a lot of upkeep?

Carrier says electronic models often include a mechanical pre-filter that must be replaced regularly (Carrier). Carrier also says many purifier filters need replacing every six to 12 months, depending on the filter type and the maker's recommendations (Carrier).

Related

Questions about a specific system can go to Blume Mechanical Service at (727) 330-9131.

Sources: Carrier, Air Purifiers for Allergies, https://www.carrier.com/residential/en/ca/products/indoor-air-quality/air-purifiers/air-purifiers-for-allergies/ · Trane, Do Air Purifiers Help Allergies and Asthma?, https://www.trane.com/residential/en/resources/blog/do-air-purifiers-help-allergies-asthma/ · U.S. EPA, HERO database, Effects of the Use of Air Purifier on Indoor Environment and Respiratory System among Healthy Adults, https://hero.epa.gov/reference/7506651/ · Bryant, Air Purifier for Allergies, https://www.bryant.com/en/us/products/air-purifiers/best-air-purifier-for-allergies/

Search Google for does an air purifier help with allergies