Blume Mechanical ServiceBlumeMechanical Service

HVAC, explained

DIY box fan air cleaners: EPA research and safety

DIY air cleaners are made by attaching one or more furnace filters to a box fan with tape, brackets, or a bungee cord (EPA). EPA recommends using them only when products of known performance are not available or affordable (EPA). EPA says DIY air cleaners are not recommended as a permanent alternative to those products (EPA).

This page covers the do-it-yourself box fan air cleaner that EPA describes for wildfire smoke events. It sets out what EPA says about the design, the research on its performance, and the safety steps for the fan itself. The sources are EPA pages, and each fact names EPA. The final section covers fan speed and the EPA infographic.

What a box fan air cleaner is

DIY air cleaners are made by attaching one or more furnace filters to a box fan with tape, brackets, or a bungee cord (EPA). The device can serve as a temporary alternative to commercial air cleaners (EPA).

EPA describes a box fan with a high-efficiency filter as a DIY portable air cleaner that filters indoor air (EPA). Some common designs place one filter flat against the fan, or form a triangle or cube of filters taped against the fan (EPA).

When EPA says to use one

EPA recommends using DIY air cleaners only when products of known performance are not available or affordable (EPA). If you cannot get a portable air cleaner with a known CADR, you may choose to use a DIY air cleaner as an alternative (EPA). If portable air cleaners are not available or affordable, DIY air cleaners can be used as an alternative (EPA).

DIY air cleaners are not recommended as a permanent alternative to these products (EPA).

What the research shows

EPA has evaluated three common DIY air cleaner designs, which have been shown to effectively reduce levels of particles in indoor air (EPA). Several studies indicate that well-built DIY air cleaners can perform similarly to commercial portable air cleaners in reducing airborne particles, such as those in wildfire smoke (EPA).

EPA notes that commercial air cleaners with a known clean air delivery rate are typically preferred over DIY air cleaners (EPA). DIY air cleaner CADRs vary based on their design (EPA).

Why performance varies

Each DIY air cleaner may perform differently, even after reassembling the same unit when changing filters (EPA). In general, DIY air cleaner designs that use more filters are more effective (EPA).

Box fan safety

Fans built before 2012 may pose fire risks (EPA). If you must use a fan built before 2012, do not leave it unattended or use it while sleeping (EPA).

EPA says to follow the box fan manufacturer's instructions (EPA). EPA gives examples, including not leaving children unattended when the fan is in use (EPA).

EPA also says not to use an extension cord, and not to use a damaged or malfunctioning fan (EPA). Make sure there are working smoke detectors throughout the home (EPA).

Choosing a fan

Use a newer box fan built in 2012 or later, and look for one with a UL or ETL safety marking (EPA).

Filters and when to change them

During periods of heavy smoke, plan to replace the filter more often than the manufacturer recommends (EPA). Have extra filters on hand and change the filter when it appears dirty or starts to release smoke odors (EPA).

Check the filters on a portable or DIY air cleaner frequently and change them when they appear dirty (EPA).

Running the unit and where HVAC fits

Run a DIY air cleaner as often as possible on the highest fan speed (EPA). EPA also points to an infographic for directions on how to build one (EPA).

Blume Mechanical Service repairs, installs and maintains HVAC and refrigeration equipment, and it is brand-agnostic.

Frequently asked

What is a DIY box fan air cleaner?

DIY air cleaners are made by attaching one or more furnace filters to a box fan with tape, brackets, or a bungee cord (EPA). EPA describes a box fan with a high-efficiency filter as a DIY portable air cleaner (EPA). EPA describes common designs with one filter flat against the fan (EPA).

When should a DIY air cleaner be used?

EPA recommends using DIY air cleaners only when products of known performance (such as commercially available portable air cleaners) are not available or affordable (EPA). If you cannot get a portable air cleaner with a known CADR, you may choose to use a DIY air cleaner as an alternative (EPA).

Do DIY air cleaners perform like commercial units?

Several studies indicate that well-built DIY air cleaners can perform similarly to commercial portable air cleaners in reducing airborne particles (EPA). Each DIY air cleaner may perform differently, even after reassembling the same unit when changing filters (EPA). Commercial air cleaners with a known CADR are typically preferred over DIY air cleaners (EPA). EPA has evaluated three common DIY air cleaner designs, which have been shown to effectively reduce levels of particles in indoor air (EPA).

Is a box fan safe to run as an air cleaner?

Fans built before 2012 may pose fire risks (EPA). Use a newer box fan built in 2012 or later, with a UL or ETL safety marking (EPA). EPA says to follow the box fan manufacturer's instructions, and not to use an extension cord (EPA). EPA also says not to use an extension cord, and not to use a damaged or malfunctioning fan (EPA).

How often should DIY air cleaner filters change?

During periods of heavy smoke, plan to replace the filter more often than the manufacturer recommends (EPA). Check the filters frequently and change them when they appear dirty (EPA). Have extra filters on hand and change the filter when it appears dirty or starts to release smoke odors (EPA).

Do more filters make a DIY air cleaner work better?

In general, DIY air cleaner designs that use more filters are more effective (EPA). EPA says commercial air cleaners with a known CADR are typically preferred over DIY air cleaners (EPA).

Related

Need an HVAC check on the central system filter or air handler in your Florida home? Blume Mechanical Service (CAC-1822618) repairs, installs and maintains HVAC and refrigeration equipment in Pinellas, Hillsborough and Pasco counties. Call 727-330-9131.

Sources: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) — Create a Clean Room to Protect Indoor Air Quality During a Wildfire (https://www.epa.gov/emergencies-iaq/create-clean-room-protect-indoor-air-quality-during-wildfire) · U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) — Wildfires and Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) (https://www.epa.gov/emergencies-iaq/wildfires-and-indoor-air-quality-iaq) · U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) — Strategies to Reduce Exposure Indoors (https://www.epa.gov/wildfire-smoke-course/strategies-reduce-exposure-indoors)

Search Google for DIY box fan air cleaner