HVAC, explained
Is an Air Purifier Worth It?
A portable air purifier with a mechanical filter can trap airborne particles from the air that moves through it, and Bryant says it generally serves a single room or space (Bryant). No air purifier can remove every airborne contaminant, according to Carrier, and an EPA-listed study of 32 healthy adults reported that the indoor PM2.5 decrease with true purifiers was not significant and found no demonstrable impact on health (Carrier; EPA HERO).
Indoor air can contain dust, dust mites and pet dander, along with pollen, mold spores, bacteria and viruses, and gases known as VOCs (Carrier). Carrier says forced-air systems such as a central air conditioner and furnace can circulate these particles throughout your home (Carrier). Bryant says whether an air purifier is worth it depends on your goals, your HVAC system and the type of unit you are considering (Bryant).
Where a portable unit does its work
Bryant says portable units generally cover one room or area, while whole-home models connect to compatible heating and cooling equipment (Bryant). Carrier says a portable room unit can help when you want to target one specific room (Carrier). Bryant lists the area you want to address among the points to weigh when choosing between the two types (Bryant).
What the filter types can catch
Carrier says a mechanical filter uses mesh to trap particles, and that a basic 1-inch furnace filter can grab dust, pet dander and bigger particles (Carrier). Carrier says pleated filters, with 4-inch pleated filters common, can filter more effectively because of their larger surface area (Carrier). Carrier calls HEPA, short for high efficiency particulate air, the most effective mechanical filter, and ties its requirement to particles 0.3 microns in diameter (Carrier). Bryant says its Evolution Air Purifier runs MERV 15 filtration, and its particle-capture results for 1.0 to 3.0 microns come from third-party testing (Bryant).
What ionic, carbon and UV models add
Carrier says ionic purifiers can be effective on smaller particles such as those found in smoke, but may be less effective on larger particles like dust or pollen (Carrier). Carrier says activated carbon filters are suited to controlling odors from VOCs common in home construction and renovation, and that not all odors are attracted to them (Carrier). Bryant says its Preferred Carbon Air Purifier with UV has a carbon core designed to help reduce common household gases and odors (Bryant). Carrier says UV purifiers use ultraviolet lamps against microorganisms like fungal spores, bacteria and viruses, and that in residential use they are usually aimed at the interior of HVAC systems, including the indoor coil, with new lamps needed each year (Carrier).
What the EPA-listed study found
A study listed in EPA's HERO database examined how air purifiers affect the indoor environment and the respiratory system of healthy adults (EPA HERO). It was a randomized crossover study of 32 healthy people, who used true air purifiers for 4 weeks and sham units for 4 weeks, with a washout period between the two (EPA HERO). Indoor PM2.5 concentrations were lower with the true units than with the sham units, but the study reports that decrease as not significant, with p equal to 0.08 (EPA HERO). Lung function did not improve significantly with purification, the study reports (EPA HERO). The authors conclude that purifiers slightly improved indoor PM2.5 in ordinary homes, with no demonstrable effect on health (EPA HERO).
What makers say a unit cannot do
Carrier says no air purifier can remove all airborne contaminants, though reliable options can reduce many household contaminants, including some odors (Carrier). Carrier says a unit may fall short on certain pollutants, such as larger particles or gases, depending on filter type (Carrier). Bryant says one technology should not automatically be treated as a substitute for another, and that filtration, carbon and UV each perform different functions (Bryant).
What upkeep the makers describe
Carrier says mechanical filters need replacing on the maker's schedule, often every 1 to 3 months, and that keeping one in too long can cut HVAC efficiency (Carrier). Carrier says electrostatic collector plates lose efficiency as particles build up, so cleaning them or replacing the filter media keeps filtering efficient (Carrier). Bryant says electronic air cleaners may need periodic cleaning or replacement, and that maintenance needs differ by product (Bryant). Bryant tells owners to follow the operating and maintenance directions for their specific model (Bryant).
Ratings to compare
Carrier says a higher MERV rating means a better filter, and that CADR measures the volume of filtered air a cleaner delivers (Carrier). Carrier says CADR is scored separately for tobacco smoke, pollen and dust (Carrier). Bryant says CADR is used for portable air cleaners, and that MERV is used for HVAC air filters (Bryant). Bryant says to compare the rating that fits the type of unit instead of relying on a single specification (Bryant).
Frequently asked
Do air purifiers really improve air quality?
Carrier says air purifiers can improve air quality by capturing allergens, dust, pollen, smoke and other pollutants (Carrier). Carrier adds that results depend on the filter type and the pollutants present, and that air purifiers are most effective when used alongside good ventilation and regular cleaning (Carrier).
How do I know if my air purifier is working?
Bryant says the answer depends on the type of equipment, and that filter-based systems need the filter replaced on the product's schedule (Bryant). Bryant says the Evolution Air Purifier can offer True Sense dirty filter detection when linked to an Evolution Connex Control (Bryant).
Should I run an air purifier every day?
Bryant says operating recommendations depend on the product (Bryant). Bryant says its Preferred Carbon Air Purifier with UV treats air continuously while the HVAC system is running (Bryant).
Do air purifiers help with dust?
Bryant says mechanical filtration can trap airborne particles while air passes through the filter, and that how many are captured depends on the filter's efficiency (Bryant). Carrier says a basic furnace filter can attract dust and pet dander (Carrier).
Do I need to call a pro for this?
Maybe. Changing the filter on the schedule the maker gives is a homeowner task (Carrier; Bryant). Bryant lists HVAC system compatibility as a factor to weigh before buying a whole-home unit (Bryant), so have a licensed contractor check how a whole-home unit would connect to your heating and cooling equipment before you buy or install one.
Related
- Room or Whole-House Air Purifier: Which Fits?
- How do air purifiers work? A homeowner's guide
- CADR ratings: how to choose a portable air cleaner
- HEPA Filters and Home HVAC: What They Are and Whether Your System Can Use One
- How to Tell if an Air Purifier Is Working
Questions about a specific system can go to Blume Mechanical Service at (727) 330-9131.
Sources: EPA HERO, Effects of the Use of Air Purifier on Indoor Environment and Respiratory System among Healthy Adults (Yoda et al.), https://hero.epa.gov/reference/7506651/ · Carrier, Do Air Purifiers Work, https://www.carrier.com/residential/en/ca/products/indoor-air-quality/air-purifiers/do-air-purifiers-work/ · Bryant, Do Air Purifiers Work And Are They Worth It?, https://www.bryant.com/en/ca/products/air-purifiers/do-air-purifiers-work-and-are-they-worth-it/