HVAC, explained
Questions to ask before buying alternative refrigerant
Alternative refrigerants are substitutes for CFC or HCFC refrigerants (EPA). EPA's SNAP program determines the risks these alternatives may pose to human health and the environment (EPA). The SNAP review does not determine whether a refrigerant will perform adequately in your system (EPA).
Buying a substitute refrigerant involves more than comparing prices. If you own a Tampa Bay home with central air or a heat pump, the questions below help you check legal status and risks. They also cover performance, warranties, equipment and cost before you pay. Each fact names its source in parentheses, so you can see which statements come from EPA and which are questions to put to your supplier.
What SNAP status tells you
EPA's SNAP program determines the risks that alternatives to CFC or HCFC refrigerants may pose to human health and the environment (EPA). EPA evaluates an alternative's ozone-depleting potential, global warming potential, flammability, and toxicity (EPA).
EPA may place conditions or restrictions on how an alternative can be used (EPA). A refrigerant can therefore be acceptable and still carry use conditions that apply to your job.
If you bought refrigerant during the SNAP review and EPA later finds it unacceptable, you may be left with a large supply that no one can legally use (EPA).
Ask your supplier whether the refrigerant is accepted under SNAP and whether any use conditions apply. Ask for the answer in writing.
What the SNAP review does not test
The SNAP evaluation does not determine whether an alternative will provide adequate performance (EPA). It also does not determine whether the alternative will be compatible with the components of an A/C or refrigeration system (EPA).
EPA names the manufacturer of the system and its components as the source of information on how a substitute will perform in a system (EPA). Those two checks are separate from the SNAP listing, so a listed refrigerant still needs its own fit check.
Ask the system manufacturer what it says about the refrigerant and whether the refrigerant is compatible with your equipment. Keep the reply with your service records for the system.
No do-it-yourself exemption
Note that there is no do-it-yourself exemption from SNAP requirements (EPA).
EPA says both service technicians and do-it-yourselfers who use alternatives found unacceptable under SNAP, or ignore use conditions, have violated the Clean Air Act (EPA).
Section 608 of the Clean Air Act establishes the National Recycling and Emission Reduction Program (EPA). The Clean Air Act prohibits individuals from intentionally venting ozone-depleting substances (ODS) refrigerants and their substitutes while servicing or disposing of air conditioning or refrigeration equipment (EPA).
If a service company offers to add a substitute refrigerant, ask which SNAP listing applies and which use conditions it must follow.
Warranties and component compatibility
For motor vehicle air conditioners, many component manufacturers have stated that their warranties will be voided if any refrigerant other than R-12 or R-134a is charged (EPA). That statement covers motor vehicles, but it shows why warranty terms need checking.
EPA says you should determine whether charging a system with a new refrigerant will void any warranty (EPA). Warranty terms can differ between the equipment maker and the parts maker.
Because equipment types and designs vary widely, EPA does not issue retrofit procedures (EPA). Ask the equipment maker about switching to a new refrigerant.
Check the warranty terms in writing before any work begins, and keep a copy of the refrigerant name on the paperwork.
Equipment and certification
Equipment used by a facility to service R-12 or R-134a A/C systems may not be used to charge, recover, or recharge a blend refrigerant (EPA).
Technicians must make certain that the equipment has been certified for use with the alternative refrigerant (EPA).
Ask your service company to confirm in writing that its equipment is certified for the refrigerant it plans to use. Ask what it will do with any refrigerant it removes from your system.
Cost compared with other substitutes
Many manufacturers and distributors may point out how much less expensive their product is than the refrigerant it replaces (EPA). A lower price on one product does not show that the product fits your equipment.
Potential purchasers should compare the cost of the product with the cost of other substitutes (EPA). Compare the same measures for each option, such as the price per container, the warranty terms and the listed use conditions.
Get the comparison in writing before you buy, so the numbers and the conditions can be checked later.
Recovery, recycling and industry standards
EPA's standards for recovering and recycling refrigerants from stationary and commercial A/C and refrigeration systems are generally based on AHRI standards (EPA). The word generally means that not every standard follows that pattern.
AHRI is an air-conditioning and refrigeration manufacturers' trade association that develops standards for the industry (EPA). Ask whether the refrigerant has been evaluated by AHRI, and whether its recycled supply will meet the AHRI standard.
Some refrigerants that SNAP has found acceptable as CFC substitutes are not acceptable as HCFC substitutes (EPA). Check the name on the cylinder against the exact listing before any purchase.
Ozone and warming effects of common refrigerants
HFC-134a does not contain chlorine and therefore does not contribute to ozone depletion, although like other HFCs, it contributes to global warming (EPA). Compare listed warming values for it from another source.
HCFC-22 and all other HCFCs contribute to both ozone depletion and global warming (EPA). That is why a blend containing HCFC-22 needs a closer look before purchase.
Lab data also indicate that HCFC-22 can damage NBR nitrile and HNBR rubber hoses and O-rings (EPA). Lab data indicate that HCFC-22 is not compatible with XH-5 or XH-7 desiccant (EPA).
Ask the supplier whether any blend contains HCFC-22 as a major component, and whether the hoses and seals in your system are rated for it.
Frequently asked
What does EPA's SNAP program determine about an alternative refrigerant?
EPA's SNAP program determines the risks that alternatives to CFC or HCFC refrigerants may pose to human health and the environment (EPA). EPA may place conditions or restrictions on how an alternative can be used (EPA).
Does a SNAP listing mean the refrigerant will work in my system?
No. The SNAP evaluation does not determine whether the alternative will provide adequate performance or will be compatible with the components of an A/C or refrigeration system (EPA). EPA names the manufacturer of the system and its components as the source of information on how a substitute will perform (EPA).
Can a homeowner use a substitute refrigerant without the SNAP rules?
Note that there is no do-it-yourself exemption from SNAP requirements (EPA). EPA says do-it-yourselfers who use alternatives found unacceptable under SNAP, or ignore use conditions, have violated the Clean Air Act (EPA).
Could a new refrigerant void my equipment warranty?
EPA says you should determine whether charging a system with a new refrigerant will void any warranty (EPA). For motor vehicle air conditioners, many component manufacturers have stated that their warranties will be voided if any refrigerant other than R-12 or R-134a is charged (EPA).
Is a cheaper refrigerant always the better choice?
Potential purchasers should compare the cost of the product with the cost of other substitutes (EPA). Many manufacturers and distributors may point out how much less expensive their product is than the refrigerant it replaces (EPA).
Why do some blend refrigerants need different service equipment?
Equipment used by a facility to service R-12 or R-134a A/C systems may not be used to charge, recover, or recharge a blend refrigerant (EPA). Technicians must make certain that the equipment has been certified for use with the alternative refrigerant (EPA).
Related
- Net-zero homes: energy and indoor air
- When does Florida cool down in fall?
- Indoor Air Quality at Home: How to Monitor It and How to Improve It
Need a refrigerant check on the air conditioner or heat pump in your home? Blume Mechanical Service (license CAC-1822618) repairs, installs and maintains HVAC and refrigeration equipment in Pinellas, Hillsborough and Pasco counties. Call 727-330-9131.
Sources: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency — Ten Questions to Ask Before You Purchase An Alternative Refrigerant (https://www.epa.gov/snap/ten-questions-ask-you-purchase-alternative-refrigerant) · U.S. Environmental Protection Agency — Stationary Refrigeration and Air Conditioning (https://www.epa.gov/section608)
Search Google for alternative refrigerant purchase questions